Would Lucy Liu still be branded a racist had she described Pinoys as “tall and fair-skinned?”

LUCY Liu: Is she afraid of tan lines, too?

ARE we going through another Teri Hatcher moment? Cyberspace is once more abuzz as angry Filipinos make their sentiments known over a supposedly racist remark Hollywood actress Lucy Liu said on “The Late Show with David Letterman.”

Liu, an American fitness buff of Chinese extraction, when asked whether she enjoyed running indoors or outdoors, said: “I run on a machine—it’s easier for me. Also, if I get really dark, I’ll start to look like a little Filipino. It wouldn’t match if I start getting darker.”

Her statement ruffled the feathers of not a few balat-sibuyas (onion-skinned) Pinoys the world over, who expressed their umbrage via social networking sites, in no time. Some reportedly even went as far as calling Liu a “cross-eyed Chink.”

No insults intended

Liu’s publicist had to issue a public apology, pronto, through Filipino journalist Ruben Nepales, Philippine Daily Inquirer’s LA correspondent: “I’m sorry that my comment was taken out of context, as I would never insult another group or ethnicity.”

TERI Hatcher, if you know what’s good for you, don’t you dare get sick in Manila.

As of this writing, Liu has yet to answer Nepales’ follow-up question as to why she used the phrase “little Filipino” if she had been concerned about the consistency of her character’s skin color in the TV series “Elementary.”

Why, would it sound less racist had Liu said “little Vietnamese,” “little Thai,” or “little Malaysian?” Would Liu be getting this flak had she said “tall and fair-skinned Filipino?”

As racist as the KKK

I would have probably empathized with a good number of Filipinos over what they perceived as a racist remark if it hadn’t been for the fact that I’m a Filipino myself. It takes one to know one. And I know in my heart that not a few Filipinos are as racist as the Ku Klux Klan.

The fact that we reacted collectively over Liu’s remark hinting that we’re small and dark is in itself very telling. It’s as if we’re ashamed of the fact that Filipinos are generally tinier and darker than most people, particularly Caucasians. Whether we care to admit it or not, looking “white” is still the gold standard as far as our idea of beauty is concerned.

DID you really ask us to leave, Mimi?

Why, what’s wrong with being diminutive and dusky? Do these seemingly negative qualities lessen our intelligence and humanity?

Liu, based on the report I read, never said that there was anything wrong with being dark and squat. As a petite Asian herself, she probably identified most with Pinoys had she been born several shades darker than her actual color.

In contrast, I clearly remember a Pinoy stage mother complaining publicly in disbelief when her fair and statuesque beauty queen-daughter lost to two other contestants in an international beauty contest in the early ’90s.

The woman, who later gained notoriety for settling scores on Twitter, said: “Ay, ang anak ko tinalo ng dalawang negra!” (Oh [no], two blacks edged out my daughter!)

The N word

I’m being kind here by using the word black. For all I know, she probably meant “nigger.” From the way she sounded, she found it unthinkable that her mestiza daughter would only play second fiddle to her dark-skinned rivals. Bakit? (Why?)

I also remember quite well this singer-actress, whose handlers initially tried to package as the new Sharon Cuneta (until the real Sharon reportedly made her feelings known since both of them belonged to the same production outfit), giggling foolishly on TV over the fact that she regularly has her hair straightened: “Kung hindi, hi-hi-hi, mukha na akong Aeta.” (Had I done away with it [hair straightening], LOL, I would have looked like an Aeta.)

TOMMY Hilfiger, only for the fair and tall?

To the uninitiated, Aetas are an ethnic minority and considered the first inhabitants in the Philippines. Because of their short stature, dark skin and kinky hair, Spanish conquistadores took to calling them Negritos or little Negroes.

Had Twitter already existed during those days, I would have probably tweeted this reaction: “Aeta? Girl, even the biggest and most muscular Aeta is no match to your six-pack abs!”

Maids and houseboys

For generations, even local TV based in Manila is guilty of reinforcing certain stereotypes and dishing out some form of regional slur on certain Filipinos. It has become a cliché, for example, for actors in sitcoms to play maids and houseboys with thick Visayan accents.

ARE you “Waspy” enough?

This latest firestorm reminded me of an unconfirmed report circulating in cyberspace years ago, before the advent of Facebook and Twitter, about supposed racial slurs made by such American clothing brands as Tommy Hilfiger and Abercrombie & Fitch against Filipinos.

Hilfiger, the brand’s owner and chief designer, reportedly said in an interview that although Filipinos love his clothes, they don’t look good on them because they’re short and dark.

Abercrombie, on the other hand, reportedly had to deny publicly that they were assigning their Pinoy staff in stockrooms because they don’t reflect the brand’s overall image. In keeping with Abercrombie’s Waspy packaging, only “typical” Americans (preferably blond and blue-eyed) are allowed to deal directly with customers.

Even Mariah Carey became the target of rumormongers. The R&B diva was holding a concert in one American city when she reportedly asked her fans: “Are there Filipinos in the house?”

Get out?

When Pinoys in the audience stood up to be recognized, Mariah reportedly said these two short words: “Get out!” Of course, these urban legends remained legends in the absence of damning evidence.

PINOYS take umbrage at being called short and dark. This in itself is very telling.

With a smoking gun that eventually went viral, Liu’s case is different. Before her, Hatcher found herself in hot water among Filipinos for lines mouthed by her character in “Desperate Housewives” about how poor the state of medical education in the Philippines is. Unlike Liu, Hatcher, or, more specifically, the show’s writers, had it coming.

Filipinos, of course, have every right to react. We may be a happy and fun-loving people, but we’ve also shown that we’re not taking such unfair generalizations bordering on racial slurs such as Hatcher’s sitting down.

But as we make our feelings known, let’s also remember that we’re also guilty of various forms of racial discrimination not only against other people but also against our own. Lighten up, guys! It would also help if we do a thorough self-examination first before we hit the post button.

4 thoughts on “Would Lucy Liu still be branded a racist had she described Pinoys as “tall and fair-skinned?”

  1. What if Lucy had said “I don’t dye my hair blonde b/c I’ll start to look a little Japanese” referring to the Japanese practice of lightening up their hair. would this be considered rascist? Honestly, the Filipinos’ reaction just show their own insecurities!

    • Gigi, I hate to imagine the consequences of that scenario you just imagined. I won’t be surprised if that ignites World War III. Knowing how the Chinese and Japanese historically hate each other, there would have been blood had Lucy said that. 😉 At least, where Pinoys are concerned, there are only plenty of saliva and sore fingers, as we raise our voices and type all sorts of comments that betray our true feelings as one of the region’s biggest racists. I agree with you. It’s sad. We claim to be proficient in English, but we’re totally ignorant of irony and getting a message’s context. 😀

  2. i think Lucy Liu said, “to look a little Filipino”, and not “to look like a little Filipino”. can you see the differnce between the two phrases? the first one meant, “magmukhang MEDYO Filipino” and the other meant, “magmukhang MALIIT na Filipino”. hay….

  3. Hi, Just wanted to say that the rumor about Tommy Hilfiger was confirmed as FALSE. He is NOT racist, and never said those things. Just wanted to let you know, because it is not fair that people still say that. Here are some links I found for everybody interested. The Oprah site (where he never said those things) and the ADL (Anti-Defamation League)

    http://www.oprah.com/oprahshow/Memorable-Guests-and-Setting-It-Straight/1
    http://www.adl.org/Internet_Rumors/letter_hilfiger.htm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s